Tate yearbook editor barred from graduation over altered picture of expelled homecoming queen

The excessive faculty scholar should be tried as an grownup alongside her mother. Buzz60

The editor of Tate high school's yearbook says she changed into unfairly disciplined â€" and barred from her upcoming graduation ceremony â€" for altering the yearbook to eliminate pictures of the now-expelled homecoming queen who's accused of rigging the election.

Samantha Guerrier, 18, says she became urged by using faculty directors in November to eradicate any photos of Emily Grover from the yearbook. Grover made national headlines after she and her mother have been arrested for allegedly hacking into the scholar data gadget to solid fake votes to secure the crown for Grover.

Plea: Former Tate homecoming queen pleads not responsible to rigging homecoming election

Samantha Guerrier

 (photograph: Courtesy of Samantha Guerrier)

dealing with a good deadline with few different photograph alternatives, Guerrier and her team decided to add a bucking horse mascot decal â€" the identical kind used on other pages within the yearbook â€" over Grover's face in a gaggle photograph earlier than submitting pages to the writer.

After the yearbook became disbursed previous this month, uproar over the altered picture led directors to droop Guerrier for the ultimate 4 days of her senior 12 months. She pointed out she additionally recently discovered she would now not be allowed at her school's commencement ceremony June 7. 

Guerrier is now the subject of a favored trade.org petition stressful the district reverse the college's resolution and enable her to stroll on the ceremony. As of Thursday night, the petition accumulated greater than four,one hundred signatures in just a number of days.

A horse mascot decal is placed over the face of Emily Grover, the homecoming queen who become later expelled. The yearbook's editor-in-chief become suspended because of the sticker incident.

 (photo: Courtesy of Samantha Guerrier)

part of the controversy has stemmed from the location of the horse photograph on Grover's face. The rear conclusion of the horse covers Grover's face â€" anything Guerrier talked about was an unlucky accident.

"if you appear on other pages in the e-book, the horse is displayed in exactly the same orientation and its hindlegs (are) within the air," she mentioned. "We did not even recognize we placed the rear conclusion of the horse on her face. We actually have been simply making an attempt to be sure the different girls were still in the publication. I had even forgot about it until individuals began making a large deal out of it."

“if you seem on different pages within the book, the horse is displayed in the exact same orientation and its hindlegs (are) in the air. We didn't even understand we positioned the rear end of the horse on her face. We literally were simply trying to make sure the other girls were nevertheless within the book. I had even forgot about it except americans all started making a large deal out of it.”

Samantha Guerrier

Escambia County college District Superintendent Tim Smith declined to touch upon the specifics of the incident, citing pupil privacy. Tate excessive important Rick Shackle didn't return a call soliciting for comment Thursday.

The scandal surrounding Tate high's homecoming election came to gentle previous this year after Grover and her mom, Laura Carroll, have been arrested in March. The duo allegedly used Carroll's district-broad access because the Bellview basic college assistant predominant to forged a whole lot of fraudulent votes for Grover, who became ultimately topped homecoming queen. 

A horse mascot decal is positioned on a Tate excessive school yearbook page. The sticky label become additionally placed over the face of Emily Grover, the homecoming queen who turned into later expelled.

 (picture: Courtesy of Samantha Guerrier)

Grover became expelled from college after college directors realized concerning the hacking in October. almost immediately after that, Guerrier mentioned she became advised to remove references to Grover from this 12 months's yearbook as a result of she turned into expelled.

Guerrier referred to she become given these guidelines Nov. 20, the identical day when the primary 64 pages of the yearbook had been due to the publishing company.

most effective a single image of Grover looked in those pages. The image turned into of a bunch of women in the college's car parking zone wearing crowns, which all seniors get to do, Guerrier stated. That page turned into achieved before the homecoming circumstance got here to light and the yearbook team had few different alternate options with which to change the picture, she pointed out.

"We simplest had truly now not a whole lot time at all to scan through all those 64 pages to be sure she wasn't included," Guerrier stated. "We failed to have adequate time to alternate the photograph or discover a new one that was the same so we ... as a team decided the best thing at that moment became to just cowl up her face in order that the different girls might nevertheless be featured on that web page."

The yearbook changed into ultimately posted and disbursed this month, which is when the photo of Grover's face with a horse decal circulated extensively on social media. it really is also when Guerrier got in hindrance for the incident.

'The faculty used my daughter as a scapegoat'

The yearbook crew is in a position to add pages at once to the publisher. Guerrier talked about her yearbook sponsor is supposed to assessment all of the proofs after they're submitted, however she doesn't be aware of no matter if the trainer checked out this specific page.

Yearbook sponsor Gail Atkins, who's also an English teacher at Tate high, declined to comment on the matter Thursday.

as soon as the yearbook is printed, Guerrier pointed out or not it's delivered to the school in can also, and the yearbook sponsor and the principal can examine it before giving the adequate to start distributing them to college students.

If there changed into an argument, those adults should have caught it earlier than permitting the yearbooks to be disbursed, noted Samantha's father, Herve Guerrier.

"I feel just like the school used my daughter as a scapegoat," he referred to. "They tried to make an example out of her simply to appease these individuals that were complaining about the pictures. They fairly a whole lot punished my daughter for some thing that she is not subsequently responsible for."

Disciplinary infractions are outlined in a document referred to as the students' Rights and obligations instruction manual, which is posted every 12 months. however, that is not binding for principals if finding out an individual student's punishment for an infraction.

"Infractions will range on occasion, simply in the ranking and the characteristics of the condition," Smith pointed out. "So the college will apply that tenet however there can be variances in that."

Guerrier turned into stated for "disruption on campus." Even for the main disruption category, only one to two days of suspension is advised in the instruction manual.

Guerrier's suspension, youngsters, turned into harsher than the advice. It began may 19 and continued throughout the final day of the senior yr might also 24. because of that, she additionally overlooked a senior breakfast and a senior parade of vehicles event.

Guerrier talked about she changed into escorted off campus when she arrived to a senior adventure might also 24 to decide on up her cap and costume for commencement. When a pupil is suspended, they're now not allowed be on campus or take part in any extracurricular actions, Smith talked about.

nevertheless, Guerrier pointed out she notion she could be allowed to participate in her graduation ceremony, primarily since it is scheduled more than two weeks after her suspension ended.

She only learned that she couldn't take part after seeing rumors on social media and texting her information counselor. The counselor proven that because Guerrier become suspended from school on the closing day, she also could not attend senior awards, breakfast or commencement, in line with text messages provided to the news Journal.

Assistant main in Tate high homecoming queen scandal pleads not guilty

Reactions: Homecoming queen election fraud shocks Tate excessive students

"it be very frustrating. or not it's very degrading. individually, she acquired treated like a criminal, like an outlaw," Herve Guerrier referred to of his daughter. "She received treated like someone who dedicated a criminal offense. And the worst of it's, actually to me, the school may still've taken responsibility as a result of she's a scholar. She's now not an employee of a corporation the place you sign contract with."

Principals have the authority to droop students for up to 10 days, Smith talked about. Participation in actions like graduation is additionally as much as the main, who could make a decision on a student.

"every so often infractions suit up fairly clearly with the guiding principle, but occasionally the essential or the assistant important is going to have to make the optimal interpretation they could and observe that code of behavior, that Rights and responsibilities, to the specific condition," he said. "You may also have a condition that truly is never recognized in the Rights and tasks manual, just as a result of the area of expertise. So then the faculty will are attempting to navigate that and put in force the Rights and duties as precisely and as smartly matched as they can."

Yearbook guidelines, techniques vary at each and every college

there isn't a district-vast policy about yearbook publishing, based on the superintendent.

methods commonly fluctuate among colleges as a result of every one is free to choose its own yearbook publishing enterprise. agencies even have different closing dates and processes, so the publishing process is commonly determined between the college and their chosen writer.

The yearbook sponsor customarily oversees the content material, and there is continually a manner where that grownup performs "edit checks" on each and every of the sections earlier than they are submitted.

"I feel what you will see from college to faculty and application to program, where it may appear in a different way, is how an awful lot autonomy college students have and the way tons checking does the sponsor have? that's a variable that a sponsor from college to faculty will sort of navigate and establish," Smith noted.

Tate excessive college yearbook editor-in-chief Samantha Guerrier works with yearbook sponsor Gail Atkins. Guerrier was suspended after a horse mascot decal turned into placed over the face of expelled homecoming queen Emily Grover.

 (image: Courtesy of Samantha Guerrier)

Principals generally get worried on an improved level, with things like the yearbook covers and subject matters. Smith referred certain questions on who reviewed Tate high's yearbook to the college itself. He observed his realizing is that the yearbook sponsor become chargeable for edit tests on submissions.

tons like there is no districtwide policy about how a yearbook is posted, there also isn't one about who can and can't seem within the yearbook.

or not it's up to particular person colleges no matter if to include expelled students in the yearbook. The primary frequently weighs which alternative could be much less disruptive to students.

"that might be a case-with the aid of-case condition," Smith pointed out. "i will tell you (what) a foremost could be pondering is, 'what is the have an effect on of those choices, if you do otherwise you do not?' The principals are pondering of the school-huge affect and affect these forms of choices could make. They can also be tough calls every so often."

Emotional rollercoaster

Guerrier noted she knew Grover and even performed tennis together with her. She said she had no malicious intent in modifying the picture and on the whole tried to keep away from the homecoming queen scandal this yr.

"I fall asleep and i might overlook concerning the condition but then waking up and logging into my mobile and seeing people are nevertheless talking about it, it's sort of just an emotional rollercoaster," she stated.

As of now, Guerrier stated she's just making an attempt to live off social media and focusing on getting capable for school. each her and her father spoke of she's been a successful pupil and has on no account gotten in quandary earlier than.

Guerrier referred to she plans to attend the institution of Florida within the fall to analyze biology on a pre-dental track.

"I feel like there's no correlation between modifying the photo and me no longer going to graduation," she stated. "I simply think find it irresistible did not warrant that in any respect and i suppose like it be in fact unfair and i started to become upset as a result of I already invited so many americans to come to graduation and americans had already taken their days off and purchased tickets and made plans to come over."

Madison Arnold can also be reached at marnold@pnj.com and 850-435-8522.

examine or Share this story: https://www.pnj.com/story/information/2021/05/27/tate-homecoming-queen-scandal-yearbook-editor-barred-graduation/7467932002/